Dagon - This one was a good introduction to Lovecraft's writings, kinda short but really interesting.
The Nameless City - Suspenseful, although the character seemed a tad naive. Honestly it took him away too long to clue in a that really annoyed me.
The Colour out of Space - It seemed kinda boring at first, but was really interesting. I actually found the ending hilarious - "I'm never drinking the Arkham water again"
The Call of Cthulhu - Of course I had to read this one.
I love how information was revealed slowly, staying very true to the thing said in the beginning; "The most merciful thing in the world, I think, is the inability of the human mind to correlate all is contents." It took a long time to piece together all the information, which made it very suspenseful and interesting.
The Shadow Over Innsmouth - Really liked this one. I kinda knew what was coming, but the ending was a true surprise.
The Haunter of The Dark - This one was really creepy, I liked it. However I noticed a bit of a flaw - If yog-sothoth can't be in the light, then what about moonlight?? It would never be able to go anywhere, really. Although I suppose it was raining when the story took place so the moon would have been hidden. You win this time, Yog-Sothoth! *shakes fist at sky*