Book Review: The Best of All Possible Worlds by Karen Lord
Okay, so this one comes with the necessary disclaimer that it was an instance of me deciding to give a fair trial to a book that I normally would have passed over because it got a good review. (Hint: it's a romance. A romance with a science fiction setting, but still very much a romance.)
The plot in a nutshell is that of an alien (but humanoid, and distantly related to humans) race who survived an attempted genocide that also wiped out their home world, and the efforts of the survivors and their human allies to preserve both their bloodlines and their culture - which, since the survivors were overwhelmingly male, necessitated arranging marriages with the natives who were best able to help them do that.
As a romance, I'd say that it was... not amazing, but decent. Then again, when it comes to romance my "decent" might as well be another person's glowing endorsement. The most refreshing aspect of the romance between the mains was the complete lack of melodrama; yes, they had their disagreements and culture clashes, but on the whole resolved them respectfully and with a minimum of angst, and the narrative managed to avoid most of your typical unhealthy relationship tropes between the main couple. No controlling behavior passed off as romance, no slap-slap-kiss, just two characters who got along well from the beginning and gradually realized they liked each other more. There's nothing wrong with that, and I wish more writers would realize that bucketloads of interpersonal angst does not an interesting romance make. Yes, there was some legitimate angst - but it felt real, and with good reason, and not overdone.
If I had one complaint about this book, it was that I found the various side plots to be more interesting than the main event - but then, this is me, so take that with a grain of salt. Still, I wish more time had been spent on the political aftermath of the genocide, on the heroine's troubles with her family, and on some of the cultures they encountered along the way. This book could have stood to be longer - it could even have stood to be a whole series. Of course, a series would also leave room for a lot of obnoxious "Will they or won't they", so maybe it's just as well.
Overall? Not exactly my cup of tea, but if you're someone who likes romance more than I you might very well enjoy it.