Played and finished recently:
Night in the Woods > [completed both storylines] looks like a kinda goofy game with anthropomorphic animals, kinda trashy humor, mostly about very millenial problems by day; by night however, the game takes on a quite different atmosphere and orientation; some specific aspects of the characters' stories resonated with me more than I expected.
Year Walk > [got the standard and alternative endings] Myst but horror; interesting; the puzzles weren't very intuitive at the beginning, I think I solved one or two by accident, but eventually I got into the logic of the game. Good atmosphere, but didn't really touch me emotionally.