The Stand Still, Stay Silent Fan-Forum

Worlds and Stories => SSSS & ARTD Board => Topic started by: catbirds on October 21, 2021, 07:49:47 PM

Title: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: catbirds on October 21, 2021, 07:49:47 PM
I figured since a couple of us have been lamenting the end of SSSS, between the personal board, comment section, and the latest page chitchat, it might be good to have a thread to write our thoughts on it here.

So here's a thread for all of us to write about our feelings, memories, and thoughts about the end of the comic, and maybe reflect a little. Maybe appreciating the journey, or the friends that you've met along the way, or how you've been inspired by it, or maybe even critiques about things that you thought would get better about the story but just didn't.

Better yet, what'll you be looking forward to in the future, how you'll interpret or make derivative works of SSSS in the future, things you want to do in the community that formed around it, and anything else you can think of. I don't want this to be a totally tearful end! This comic meant a lot to me and I'm sure it was the same for many others, so I want us to look back on it happily and bravely! Maybe if you're looking forward to Minna's future work, if you did sign up for updates on that? I haven't personally, but I'm a little curious about it. Though the contents of that story should probably be discussed in a separate thread since this one's about SSSS.

Feel free to share any of your thoughts and feelings that you're comfortable sharing! And discuss them with others! It might be a bit early, but I think it'd be nice to talk about it so we aren't flooded with feelings at the very end and can go through it slowly together.

(The general discussion about the future of the fandom can be found here (https://ssssforum.com/index.php?topic=1176.0))

The title of the thread is a bit of a misnomer because SSSS isn't guaranteed to be gone forever, but also the amount of uncertainty about the comic's future means that it could just end with adventure 2.



My own thoughts!

I've been keeping up with SSSS for over 4 years now, and I still think it had a lot of nice, emotional moments that are down-to-earth and realistic, especially in the first adventure, and I loved the usual fare of nice worldbuilding and great art. That was probably why a lot of people were so attached to it! Outputting pages so regularly and with consistent quality for so many years is something that is rarely seen for comics. One of my favourite examples of this was the part around adventure 1, page 833, because the combination of blue hues and the character interactions made the sense of melancholy of the situation almost tangible. Also, I've gotten so attached to the characters over the years that their growth and development makes me happy, in such a way that few characters from other media can achieve the same thing. It's great that even though the premise of the comic sounded like the characters would be stereotypes of their respective comics, they ended up having emotional developments and characteristics that set themselves apart from the crowd and give them all a much more human quality.

Spoiler: suuuuuper long post • show

Watching Minna's Saturday streams was what made me want to start posting and sharing art, which is a big reason for why I started developing my art skills at all! I couldn't have gotten anywhere near where I am now without SSSS and the community around it, and it probably influenced my decisions for uni and my future plans too. It's a huge part of my life and I'm definitely happier for it. As sad as I am that it's ending soon, I am still so grateful for what I've gotten out of this series. Doing art is one of the few ways I can imagine myself in the future.

A lot of people were confused by the wavering quality of the last few chapters, but the last pages of chapter 15 have gotten better again. I agree that it also felt like it was getting utilitarian or mechanical at some points, but seems to be recovering now. It was probably just the uncertainty and the fact that Minna was looking forward to starting another project, which I'm happy for, even though I'm not interested in the story itself. I hope that it won't be something that has such a strict and intense update schedule, though, because it's quite worrying when an artist works too much. Something about its effects on both physical and mental health...

I've almost gotten out of a period where I don't really have anyone to look up to, though, ever since I became a bit detached from the fandom and creator. It's nice, even if it means I am missing a significant motivator... though looking back on SSSS, I can still feel the same sense of awe and inspiration that I found when I started the series.

I have a couple of minor criticisms of the story, though, but it also feels kind of unfair when you consider that SSSS was all the work of one person. For the sake of sharing, just minor things like that it doesn't really experiment as much with visuals except for occasionally in the dream world (though the art is very technically good), or that I feel like its depictions of nature were kind of aimless, or the lack of any consistently explored or overarching themes, and sometimes when the dialogue is a little stilted. They're not big issues, and for one person's comic which is never proofread or edited by another party, SSSS is still exceptional. Though the instances where she's said something offensive in the past are obviously indefensible. Even then, it makes me uneasy at times when large companies can do the same with little negative impact to their brand while an independent creator can get their entire careers ruined. It's just one of those injustices that I can't really think of a good solution for, but everyone except the corporation loses in the end. (Edit: to be clear I think we should be harder on corporations, not softer on bigoted people, but it's very hard to collectively do that)

This community, though, is definitely one of the nicer bits of the internet that I hope will continue to exist long after SSSS ends. I don't really feel like I'm as close to anyone as some of you are, but it's nice to be in a space where open discussion and organizing small events that anyone can participate in is encouraged. Especially when all other social media is super competitive in terms of creative work, this is the one place I'm in where everyone's unique creations gets shared without any pressure to get a Big Number! Umm... honestly, I'm a little more busy than I used to be in high school, though, so it's a bit harder to participate and do art in general. But it's always nice to come back here and see everyone's still here!


That's all I can think of for now! And despite everything, I still hope everything gets better for everyone.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on October 21, 2021, 10:03:15 PM
catbirds, that is a fascinating essay. For me, getting involved with an online community was a totally new experience, since I had never even read a webcomic before. While I knew they existed and occasionally my husband, who was familiar with such things because he worked with computers and the internet, would tell me about what he was reading, I had never read one myself. Eventually I also began reading Girl Genius because he liked it and showed me some good bits. Life was busy and I struggled to find time to read physical books for pleasure, little say reading things online, and apart from things that I was writing and publishing as part of my work I found little time to write for pleasure. Most of what I did write was technical reports, information handouts and articles about such subjects as botany, bushcraft, wild food foraging, folklore and traditional culture, arts and crafts. What I wrote for my own pleasure was mostly poetry, an occasional song and a bit of hard science fiction (that is, SF rather than fantasy). I am also slowly compiling a cookery book and one about wild food foraging.

Then one of my greatnieces who knew I was fond of folklore and beautiful art pointed me at A Redtail’s Dream and I went on to read Minna’s later work.

When I realised that the pages had comments I began to read them and eventually to reply to a few. Then I was introduced to the concept of fanfic and before I knew it I was writing some and have continued to do so (I am Tanist over on Archive of Our Own). I became involved in the Forum and was delighted to discover that some of my real-world skills and interests translated very well to this context and were of use and interest to others here. When I introduced some real-world friends to the comic and the Forum they liked it and have stayed, some joining in and some remaining as lurkers. I enjoy watching them have fun here.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Keep Looking on October 22, 2021, 12:22:13 AM
I started reading SSSS about two and a half years ago, although because of the craziness of my final year of high school and the monotony of the Bear Chapters I haven't really kept up with the comic much this year. But SSSS and especially this fan community hold a really special place in my heart, and looking back has had a really, really big impact on my life these past few years.

From the start of my involvement, it was the SSSS comments section and the lovely people there (many of whom are over here as well - Róisín, Grey and Jitter, I especially remember having lovely interactions with you guys in the comments) which threw me back into writing poetry. I wrote a lot of poems over 2019 and 2020 for the new pages of SSSS. Writing those poems so regularly was really fun and also honed my poetic and wordplay skills - if I look back on the poems I wrote now, I can see how much I improved! Also, a shoutout to the other poets from the comments section, many of whom I looked to for inspiration, some of whom are active now and some who are not - Nellie McEnt's lovely sonnets, ScottishNottish (I've still got their beautiful poetic soundscape (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=o0D9eE6TYRI) bookmarked on my laptop), and Corncobman, whose sheer consistency of poetic production over so many years both impresses and terrifies me. I don't really write SSSS poetry anymore (except for forum events!), but I still write poetry for myself now, and I'm planning to find some poetry groups in my city once I'm done with my exams.

SSSS also helped me stay sane and get through Covid back in 2020 - writing poems in the comments section was one little bit of consistency in my life. That was what prompted me into organising the first Chapter Break Filler event (I genuinely didn't know how I'd get through the break), in which I got to see so many creative works and also learned a lot about organising events and co-operating with other people. While Chapter Break Fillers have been taken over by others (thanks Jitter!) while my study's been ramping up, and won't really be a thing once SSSS ends, that first Chapter Break Filler was the one consistent task I could set my mind to doing in the midst of all the uncertainty of April 2020, when I wasn't sure how far Covid would spread, or whether school would go back, or how anything at all would turn out.

The Chapter Break Filler also catapulted me into becoming a skald on the forum staff. With all the chaos of the Bunny Comic and then the great forum restructuring, I actually learned a lot about working together with other people in the face of chaos, and I admire this fandom so much for being able to stick together and still maintain such a good environment despite everything that's happened. Learning how to be an admin on this site has also taught me loads about how websites work behind-the-scenes. I definitely have a much stronger admiration for my friends who study computer science after I went through the trials and tribulations of altering the site code to update the help page. If you ever want to know how you update code, the answer is: very, very slowly. Syntax errors are everywhere and they are the bane of your existence.

I've made so many friends and had so many good conversations in the comments, on the forum, and also on the SSSS discord server, and this is definitely the most and longest I've been involved in any fan community. SSSS itself and Minna were what brought me here, and I definitely went through a phase where I ardently loved and kept up with the comic itself (as well as Minna's YT videos!), and I'm sad that it's ending, but as time goes on the thing that keeps pulling me back to this place is the people.

Róisín, I have my driving license now, so expect a visit from me sometime in the next few years (maybe this winter, or the next summer around)! I've always wanted to drive across the Nullabor, anyway, I think it'd be really cool.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on October 22, 2021, 04:56:15 AM
Catbirds, thank you for this! I will get back to reading as well as sharing my own thoughts. You are absolutely right, let’s celebrate what we have.

If I may suggest, maybe we should make a separate thread for things that we hoped or excepted to see but didn’t? Firstly it might attract comments from Forumites who don’t have such strong feelings about this, or who don’t feel like sharing their feelings publicly. Secondly I expect there to be a great variety of ideas and it would be easier to follow if the thread were dedicated to that.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on October 22, 2021, 06:22:33 AM
KeepLooking, you have your licence! Hooray, Huzzah! It will be good to meet you in the flesh! Maybe if you can show me how to do so we can record some of those traditional stories you wanted. And I can show you the forest, the community garden and Recreate, our farmers market, the Gumeracha Artisans Market and if you are here for the last Saturday of the month, one of my music nights. That would be awesome!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: midwestmutt on October 22, 2021, 09:38:30 AM
Minna promised us a tale of adventure and growing friendships in a Nordic setting completely new to me and she has delivered. My only regret at this ending is the loose ends of background stories of some the characters especially Emil. The Finns were covered in good depth since this has been essentially their story. The community that grew around the comic was an unexpected delight which became a part of my daily life. I found myself trying new things like haiku and exploring new places through the photos from other fans. I even got a little better at using computers so I could share in the group conversation. This comic has been unique from the start.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: tehta on October 23, 2021, 06:08:24 PM
I feel a bit sheepish here, since I only discovered SSSS in June. I remember most of my first read-through (staying up late to see how the fight with Sleipnope would turn out, loving the Iceland content, then wondering at the change in the art) and then my adventures on AO3 (noticing how high-quality the writing was, wondering why so many writers seemed to have stopped a year or two back, leaving comments and finding out the reason...) But then, I got bitten by the fanfic bug for the first time in years, and remembered how much I love writing. And, somewhere along the line, I started poking my toe into the fandom, and I agree with what many of you state or suspect: this fandom is special. I have been a part of several others, and watched a few more from the sidelines, and this one just feels so welcoming and pleasant and mature.

I am left with two thoughts:
One event I think I would like to see is some kind of post-comic challenge with in-universe continuation stories due a couple of months after the story ends, to give people time to process whatever happens.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: catbirds on October 24, 2021, 12:32:35 AM
Catbirds, thank you for this! I will get back to reading as well as sharing my own thoughts. You are absolutely right, let’s celebrate what we have.

If I may suggest, maybe we should make a separate thread for things that we hoped or excepted to see but didn’t? Firstly it might attract comments from Forumites who don’t have such strong feelings about this, or who don’t feel like sharing their feelings publicly. Secondly I expect there to be a great variety of ideas and it would be easier to follow if the thread were dedicated to that.

And thank you for making that thread! It felt like a brainstorm thread that just jogged my memory a liiittle bit. There were just a couple things that I totally forgot about until I started writing something, especially considering pages come out over several long, long years (and my memory is bad!)

Honestly my thoughts are pretty scattered on everything, too. We'll probably need many more end-of-SSSS threads as the end draws near.

I became involved in the Forum and was delighted to discover that some of my real-world skills and interests translated very well to this context and were of use and interest to others here. When I introduced some real-world friends to the comic and the Forum they liked it and have stayed, some joining in and some remaining as lurkers. I enjoy watching them have fun here.

Yeah, pretty much everything you know has been super interesting to hear about! It's actually really rare to have an internet community with people that have quite as much wisdom (and as many skills) as you and all others in this forum have collectively. I've been in a lot of online communities for much shorter periods of time, and nothing's ever been quite like this forum :o

SSSS also helped me stay sane and get through Covid back in 2020 - writing poems in the comments section was one little bit of consistency in my life. That was what prompted me into organising the first Chapter Break Filler event (I genuinely didn't know how I'd get through the break), in which I got to see so many creative works and also learned a lot about organising events and co-operating with other people. While Chapter Break Fillers have been taken over by others (thanks Jitter!) while my study's been ramping up, and won't really be a thing once SSSS ends, that first Chapter Break Filler was the one consistent task I could set my mind to doing in the midst of all the uncertainty of April 2020, when I wasn't sure how far Covid would spread, or whether school would go back, or how anything at all would turn out.

It's great to hear that so many others started doing something creative because of SSSS! It's definitely what I mean when I say that even if your relationship with the comic wanes, our lives (artists or not) are richer for this comic, or at least the fandom around it. Especially during Covid, since that was so bizarre and anxiety-inducing when it started that people were struggling to grab onto any consistency.

(Speaking of, one of my greatest regrets was probably leaving here in the first summer after COVID started, but what can you do! It might be odd but I feel like I could've connected more with this community rather than leave.)

The Chapter Break Fillers are a great idea, too! I've laughed and cried at so many people's creations, and they also make the experience of reading the comic so much better. And I feel like daily sign-up formats are something that this forum is exceptionally good for, especially with the comment visibility.

I hope you enjoy driving/travelling across Australia soon! <3
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on October 30, 2021, 01:23:28 PM
I was never part of a fandom before SSSS. I mean I was a general nerd as a teenager (and ever since), I played D&D (sadly that's long past now) and read Science Fiction and fantasy, you know how it is. But I never was so close with so many people in the same fandom! When I started with SSSS I tried to get my family members to read it, and my husband does but he doesn't have any passion. My sons for some reason never took the interest, I don't understand how that's possible! But anyways I wanted to have someone to talk about it with!

I have a history of spending far too much time on Facebook so I was very wary of joining the commentariat. But eventually I had to, and it was the best decision in many years! When I say eventually it sounds like I held off for a considerable time, but actually I started reading in the very beginning of on 2019, and was already on Disqus in February. I actually tried to hold off for a while after reaching end of Adventure 1, because I didn't want to wait for each page so I thought I'd let them accumulate but as you know that is impossible :) The experience of reading something is very different, once you are caught up in comparison to when you can just read the next and the next and the next page.

I have actually been in a similar situation earlier, when in my teens I was a huge fan of Elfquest, and I had the comic books mailed to me from a comic shop in another city. Postage was expensive, so I waited for a few books to come out between orders, and got about 3 issues every few months apart. Oh that was painful! Note that I was a fan but not in a fandom. There was a usenet news group (the old ones among you may remember what that was) but it was not really a community, at least for me.

The fandom has given me friends, a social outlet in the time of isolation (I live with my husband and two sons so I haven't been truly alone, but still this is very very important) and got me re-connected with my creativity, which I wrote about in another thread in the Academy board so won't repeat it here.

The comic, the characters etc. are wonderful and have enriched my life for nearly three years. However the really important thing I have gained is this community. I hope we can keep it alive! The crisis created by the Bunny Comic was really bad for me. I was sad to learn Adventure 2 would be the last one, but I was a lot more sad about losing this community. And for a bit it was looking bad. But we pulled through and we have rebuilt, and I sincerely hope we will stay here even after the comic ends for good.

But, I also hope we can keep the flame burning for SSSS and continue with the fanworks. The world exists for us now, and the characters are there, the stories are there, and it's up to us to bring them forth. The ending of canon actually frees up a lot of threads to pull on, to interpret and build on without having to wonder how the canon will be. That can be a good thing.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: crowbarrd on October 30, 2021, 07:35:55 PM
Although SSSS is not the first (or last) fandom I've been in, it's perhaps one of the fandoms I've been most dedicated to. I spent a lot of my time on Tumblr and Twitter in the past catching up with fandom content, and although I've found many amazing artists, I've always been a lurker. SSSS is probably the first time I have faced up to the fact that I'm in the fandom, contributing to the fandom and am part of the community.

Spoiler: me blathering • show
Other than playing Flight Rising, I've not had much experience with a 'forum' style of communication (?) so I suppose it has also introduced me to this style of website ! (Talking about that, I suppose this style also preserves my writing skills? In the modern age I've been losing my grasp of it amid the flood of lols and lmaos and other short forms, so it's nice to exercise it)


And I agree with JItter !! What I love most about SSSS is its community; I'm in fandoms that are toxic hellscapes, so to have such a close knit, wonderful fandom is to me like an oasis in a desert. The people here are amazing and varied, as well as not only being dedicated to SSSS but a range of things like poetry and personal interests, which is incredibly inspiring ! I really hope that even after the end of the webcomic, we'll all still be here with our fanwork  :V
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on October 30, 2021, 07:53:35 PM
Oh, Jitter, another old Elfquest fan here! And Yastreb is one more, as is Star and as are several other people we know! But despite going into Melbourne every few months to buy physical copies of the Elfquest comic from old Space Age Books, we were never in the fandom as such, though eventually I met both the Pinis and the Foglios through conventions. I in particular didn’t really have the concept of ‘fandom community’, though I had long been deeply involved in several other communities: Melbourne had long had serious communities of folk music enthusiasts, which had a considerable overlap with the pagan community, and there were also enthusiasts of reenactment and martial arts, the last two groups in particular having very few women involved, though even folk music was considered very much a male preserve. .

I had always read science fiction, but the arts community in which I had been involved was more of poets and short story writers, playwrights and novelists. SF was not regarded as being literature back then. But I was invited to my first SF convention because I had won an award for science-themed poetry, and the prize was to be presented at a science-fiction convention, one of the first held in Melbourne. I fell into the SF community very easily, and wound up being involved in the organisation of Australia’s first WorldCon. Good times!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on October 30, 2021, 08:53:20 PM
Another for the old Elfquest comics, the original run. I didn't keep up with the later stuff.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on October 30, 2021, 10:43:18 PM
I didn’t know there was later stuff!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on October 31, 2021, 07:41:05 AM
There is still later stuff! It got very complicated for many years, first with several titles and then suddenly many storylines getting published in small parts in one book (as in one typical size comic book had a bit of 3-5 storylines) which is when I lost track completely. Now they are making a single series again, but I need to catch up a bit to understand who the characters are.

But, point relevant here: I was a fan, but I was not in a fandom. There were SciFi associations in Finland by the time I was in the uni but I went once, was the only girl, didn’t feel welcome. I also went to local conventions a couple of times and enjoyed it, but didn’t really connect with anyone personally.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Vulpes on October 31, 2021, 07:51:57 PM
Several people have mentioned the parallel with finishing a much-loved book, and the odd mix of satisfaction and melancholy that produces. I'm finding the end of SSSS similar but distinct, perhaps because the end is happening in slow motion (obviously that wouldn't be the case if I weren't following as the comics come out) and with a great deal of discussion... like right here and now! I've always been a very solitary reader, and I don't recall ever discussing a book as I read it, other than in English class.

SSSS has been a lot of things - a pleasant distraction, a compelling tale, beautiful artwork, an incredible community, an inspiration to create... so of course it's sad that it will end soon, and with tales untold. But I like to remind myself that I am only aware of the untimely end and untold tales because of the way the comic is delivered, and my involvement in the fandom. If this were a finished book I stumbled on, I would read it, and say to myself, "That was a great tale, what else has she written?" and then be mildly disappointed to find that there was nothing else. I would wonder about the loose ends (Emil's burning house, Mikkel's air of mystery) and perhaps wonder why the creator stopped, but that would be it.

Like any good story that ends, I'll appreciate what it gave me, and perhaps, unlike anything else I've been sad to finish, I'll be able to come back here and see some creative takes on what happened next. Such a gift, both the comic and the community.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: ScrimmyBingusPSVitaPort on November 08, 2021, 05:25:59 PM
So this might be controversial, but with the hindsight of both adventures (recently caught up on 2, so many bears...) I'm getting the feeling that adventure 2 shouldn't have been made. I really liked the earlier parts of it but looking at it compared to adventure 1, it really feels like Minna had lost the passion for it and was just going through the motions. I know she had ideas for more adventures, but adventure 1 works pretty well as a stand alone story, albeit with a few loose ends.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on November 08, 2021, 06:06:30 PM
I suspect that when Minna started adventure 2 she was still really into it, and at that point was still expecting to continue on with further adventures after this one. The relationships of the characters at the beginning, and through that whole long stretch in which Lalli opened up to others about what had happened to his community, with the time and attention paid to what that community was like and how it worked before everything came apart -- I don't think she was just going through the motions then, I think she still loved what she was doing.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: ScrimmyBingusPSVitaPort on November 08, 2021, 06:22:13 PM
That would make sense, the Iceland parts of adventure 2 were definitely a high point IMO.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on November 09, 2021, 12:34:26 PM
I feel the same as Thorny, and based on various discussions I think many others do too. It seems to be during this adventure, not at the beginning, that the spark was lost or at least severely dimmed.

It is telling how, when she announced she will be moving to other things, she promised to take Adv 2 to a _decent_ end. That was decent of her, but of course I would have preferred it to be more than that. Still, I definitely prefer a decent ending instead of just dropping it in the middle of the story.

All in all I still am happier that she did Adventure 2 like this, than not at all. But that’s just my view.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: ScrimmyBingusPSVitaPort on November 09, 2021, 03:24:36 PM
I guess my view on adventure 2's latter half is negatively biased after certain "faith related" events made my lose my faith in Minna's writing. So I'm not really being fair to the most recent chapters. Additionally (not trying to get inflammatory, just offering more of my perspective), if adventure 2 was never made I probably would have gotten whatever volumes had been printed in 2018 (when I started reading) and be satisfied, I probably never would've stuck around long enough to see what had happened back in April. I guess my perspective's pretty selfish, but this is at least twice now that a webcomic creator I looked up to turned out to be an unpleasant person. It didn't hurt nearly as much as the first time, but it was still pretty disappointing. Maybe I can get a second hand copy of volume 2 of adventure 1 off of ebay...
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: lwise on November 09, 2021, 03:35:51 PM
I think the real problem with this adventure is the slow pacing.  Every scene seems drawn out far too long.  I didn't feel that the first adventure had that problem.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on November 09, 2021, 06:11:14 PM
I guess my view on adventure 2's latter half is negatively biased after certain "faith related" events made my lose my faith in Minna's writing.

I suspect that it was also those events, or at any rate the change in faith that caused them, which caused her to lose interest in SSSS.

Some people are quite capable of holding faith in their religion while writing, loving, and sympathizing with characters who don't share that faith and even worlds in which it's basically irrelevant. Other people aren't. Minna may unfortunately be in the second category. (yes I'm sure there are people in the middle --)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: wavewright62 on November 09, 2021, 10:40:22 PM
As already mentioned by others, Adv. 2 started quite well.  The "It" storyline was first introduced all the way back in Reynir's introduction in 2015, and supposedly Tuuri's death was necessary to advance its resolution.  (And, I *guess*? To provide a reason for Onni to bargain with the Swan? Kinda? I guess we'll see.)  That story was the impetus for Adventure 2; it had to be told.

There is the thinnest, barest, least satisfying pretext for Sigrun and Mikkel to be there.  Part of the malaise of this Adventure was their presence.  I love Sigrun & Mikkel as characters, but they seriously needed to go their own way. Even the new characters that were introduced spoke only to them, and this was not their story!  Emil was easily written in to go along, he is not the problem, and a case could be made for Reynir chasing after Onni.
I admit that in the face of any troll they came across, we would all say 'omg I wish Sigrun was here' but the story would have been so much tighter with just the two (maybe 3) of them. 

Except for the bears.  I get that a BRIEF return just to see off Surma and the bears' storyline should happen, but yeah.  With her cubs thoroughly dead-dead and no longer in need of her protection, you'd'a thunk she'd run off into the woods to mourn.  Would a bear, even a beast bear, be capable of vengeance? 

She had pacing issues in Adv. 1 too - she found herself needing to get the crew close enough to their pick-up point that they could walk there.  However, they picked up the antagonists way back at the beginning point.  So we had the spectre (geddit?) of ghosts following them doggedly for weeks in canon to get to their battle point, and then the plot had to twiddle its collective thumbs for two weeks to allow Tuuri's incubation period for the infection.  Then there were two streams to follow, and thenwegottothepickuppointhooraytheend.

Now, where I agree with ScrimmyBingus, is that Minna didn't actually script Adv 2 out in advance as she probably had Adv. 1.  She had some vague plot points to intersect - Onni goes on quest for Grandma, obtains Tuuri's assistance as a soul, Lalli & Reynir come to his aid to repay Onni's assistance when they were in Denmark, Grandma freed.  Suddenly having to accomplish that, she had difficulties.
I think she had the idea for the Sentinel Mages and had figured out where to intersect that into the story.  I think she had the idea for the Hotakainen backstory, but not the nuts 'n' bolts of how to present it. She came upon an interesting hook of presenting it as 'a time-travel dream that they all share!' which was cute but weird, especially with the bits that Lalli-the-child would never have seen himself. (note: the brief flash of anger Lalli exhibited at Emil 'it's happening all over again' - the flash of a fist against the garment - didn't happen in the flashback, sorry)  I think Surma was not originally meant to be just a troll.  I don't think she'd thought through exactly how or when Onni travels to Tuonela.

I think she orignally had a plan for why exactly she needed Tuuri to be dead to accomplish Onni's goal, hence the insistence for years beforehand that Tuuri's death was crucial for the plot.  I don't buy that it was crucial to Onni getting the cojones to go on the quest, for Tuuri to be dead and no longer needing his protection.  But I think that perhaps Minna's burgeoning faith caused her to have second thoughts about Onni's plan (perhaps involving dark rites that would make a Christian uncomfortable?).  For what actually happened in canon, Onni's dead father or uncle would have served the purpose just as well as Tuuri, maybe better. 

Any of us who have written long-form fiction get to that point where you don't know quite what to do to get from point A to point Z.  You know all kinds of cool stuff that happens at point Z, but you also know that you can't just go there in the second chapter, the end.  I postulate that Minna believed herself committed to telling a story she was no longer mentally committed to, and did not seek objective advice on the matter.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on November 10, 2021, 10:53:02 AM
I also wonder about Surma. Surma is made a very Big Deal, and a huge mystery -- and then its only purpose to the story turns out to be to distract Mama Bear from the crew? That's weird. We didn't get much backstory to the Kade, but we did get a little. I was expecting at least that much backstory for Surma, but we've had nothing at all.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Sol on December 09, 2021, 05:31:18 AM
Prepare for a long and whiny post

I have discovered SSSS in April, but I have been seeing the art while scrolling through Pinterest many times before (I even started reading it, but my poor English back then didn't allow me to understand everything so I gave up) After a year or so, I found it again. I remember how the title interested me, and the art, I couldn't believe that the WHOLE comic was illustrated like this. I think one of the first arts I saw was Lalli in the dream space and the "Hour of the wolf" artwork. So I came back and binge-read the whole thing, and was stunned. I have never found a comic that would fit my aesthetic so much. I was in love with all the characters, how they were drawn and written. I was so hyped and I noticed that there was a second part of the comic! And the video game, joining two things I love- SSSS and cyberpunk. Later on, I joined the SSSS Discord and drew my first fanart of Lalli. In the meanwhile, I started reading adv II. What I noticed was that none of the characters seemed to be impressed by what happened in the Silent Lands. And then, I got to the part when the gang entered the building to hide from the bear. I noticed "short Sigrun" on the stairs and felt so very disappointed. Then, I have learnt about Lovely people and that the COH won't be developed anymore (when the devlog disappeared I went through the WayBack machine, Minna's blog collected and organised all I have found)

And from that time on I could only see the story decreasing in terms of art and storytelling. It looks as if the author completely lost passion for the comic and do it as a chore. I could understand that maybe the pages are easier to draw this way. Bears, bears some more bears, the Kade which is not terrifying at all and so on. (I have complained about that many times on the SSSS Discord) To my mind, the new pages look weirdly rushed

But, despite all that I still love SSSS AdvI and the beginning of IInd adventure and draw fanarts. Thanks to this comic I actually improved my inking skills- I have never drawn that many fanarts for any piece of media. I also got interested in Scandinavian culture and languages and found new hobbies, such as writing and learning Norwegian. Since April, SSSS became very important for me and seeing it end this way is just sad. I only hope that after it ends the fandom won't die out. I have some SSSS-themed projects in advance, but I'm sure of one thing. I will miss the unique atmosphere the old comic had.

One last thing, I regret not joining the fandom earlier *sighs*
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on December 09, 2021, 02:15:43 PM
Solveig, do stick around! We are determined to keep the Forum going. We'll have the fanworks to hold and expand, and we are planning to do a forum re-read of Adventure 1, and so on and so fort. On the forum we are also in the process of finding new content that may be of interest to SSSS fans, most notably the Comic of the Month thread at this point.

So, you are not late from the fandom :) We intend to stick around!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: wavewright62 on December 10, 2021, 02:41:59 AM
Solveig, I have seen your drawings on Discord and adore your talent.  I agree that there's a lot still to love, even though 2021 has not been as satisfying.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Suominoita on December 10, 2021, 08:20:00 AM
 My guess as to why Tuuri: Onni doesn't want anyone with authority over him around before Grandma Ensi is released (also why he tried to avoid Väinö I guess). His younger sister though... well, now that's someone who wouldn't be telling him what to do, but can do what is needed, what with being dead already.

That his helpers ended up being the Swan, Lalli and Reynir -- well, that wasn't his plan at all. Actually he didn't seem to know what exactly he was doing as it was. Something an older relative would have told him off for and probably forbidden the whole journey.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Kevin_Redcrow on December 10, 2021, 11:36:02 PM
As disappointing as the quality of the latter part of Adventure 2 is, I believe Ms. Sundberg pressed on and finished it as a well-intended gesture to the fandom. I'm saying this as one who had not quite reached the point of reading her blogs; fans who do read them know better than I. 

I had planned to read the blogs, until some bunnies hopped along.

If Ms. Sundberg decides on a more moderate spiritual worldview, perhaps we will see an interesting project with a different setting than all her prior works.

SSSS was the 4th or 5th graphic novel i encountered online by a Finnish artist. I enjoy seeing that comic art can fall into a "National School". French, Dutch, Japanese, English, Canadian, and American comic art seem to each have a distinct flavor (Don't know if I got the grammar correct in that last sentence).

In this regard, the artist who does A Year In Hereafter has what looks like to me a style very closely resembling Ms. Sundberg's. Were the latter to sell the rights to continue SSSS, I would nominate the former to take over. YIH also leans heavily of Finnish Folklore as the background for the story.

As to the forum and the commentariat: I was mildly tempted to join the commentariat, but I dithered. Then I decided that I would not quite fit in, in the long run. My online persona vacillates between benevolent and caustic as it does in Real Time/Space.  I do not mean that I would intentionally flame somebody. Those of you who have read my remarks on the Bunny Comic Thread know that when I have a bad reaction to events and circumstances I can be very spiky.

Although when that racist, sexist poster who called himself Rabbi Blabbabogdonavich or something, showed up, I was very tempted to rethink my policy on flaming.

I believe I did join this forum very soon before the Bunny Comic. When that was published, I thought, "Oh [human excrement], I'm just going to vent my spleen until this thread dies and then not come back.

Well, here I am. I want you to know that I admire you regular long time forum members who have demonstrated only good will. Good will is something I admire but will not attain in this lifetime. 
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: catbirds on December 11, 2021, 03:13:16 AM
SSSS was the 4th or 5th graphic novel i encountered online by a Finnish artist. I enjoy seeing that comic art can fall into a "National School". French, Dutch, Japanese, English, Canadian, and American comic art seem to each have a distinct flavor (Don't know if I got the grammar correct in that last sentence).

In this regard, the artist who does A Year In Hereafter has what looks like to me a style very closely resembling Ms. Sundberg's. Were the latter to sell the rights to continue SSSS, I would nominate the former to take over. YIH also leans heavily of Finnish Folklore as the background for the story.

I've also noticed this! Minna and the artist for YIH for one. I think the author might've been inspired by Minna, considering the publishing date and, as I've heard but not seen, the appearance of Reynir? Also, a lot of popular Finnish artists seem to know a great deal about painting nature, but I think that might veer a little too close to speculation. But nature's a pretty big deal in Finland :P

Now that the forum's inspecting other comics of interest, I feel a little more at ease seeing both Finnish and non-Finnish comics that do so much better at representation and focus mostly on character development. Sticking to just SSSS was kind of limiting myself, though to be fair I didn't really know where to start. Another benefit has been seeing other approaches to page composition, visual storytelling, and symbolism, since it was pretty inflexible with SSSS.

Side note, Minna's made it pretty clear that she doesn't intend for other people to complete things she started. I'm fine with that, honestly. But hypothetically, YIH does look visually close.

Well, here I am. I want you to know that I admire you regular long time forum members who have demonstrated only good will. Good will is something I admire but will not attain in this lifetime. 

Eeeeeee... Minna's actions kind of used up any remaining goodwill I had. But she has her boundaries and even if that bunny comic personally insulted someone, she probably wasn't willing to have a debate about it anyway. It's more just energy better spent elsewhere.

But, despite all that I still love SSSS AdvI and the beginning of IInd adventure and draw fanarts. Thanks to this comic I actually improved my inking skills- I have never drawn that many fanarts for any piece of media. I also got interested in Scandinavian culture and languages and found new hobbies, such as writing and learning Norwegian. Since April, SSSS became very important for me and seeing it end this way is just sad. I only hope that after it ends the fandom won't die out. I have some SSSS-themed projects in advance, but I'm sure of one thing. I will miss the unique atmosphere the old comic had.

One last thing, I regret not joining the fandom earlier *sighs*

Solveig, I've only seen the bit of your art that's appeared on tumblr, but I think it's great and I totally get the feeling of just? learning how to do art from SSSS? This community was just super welcoming when I started posting things, IDK.

(I love your inking though <3)

Anyway, it's far from too late to join the fandom. The fact is people still love the characters, and you can still engage with the story as you choose. The specifics of that kind of debate are difficult, though, but ultimately it's up to you.

Spoiler: personal thoughts on the topic • show

A handful of people have probably spent a load of money on SSSS books, and I know that's given a few of my friends a lot of conflicting emotions recently. But also how could they have known? For me, I'm mostly at peace with talking about SSSS until the end here, since this is a pretty closed environment and most of the regular forum users have worked together to figure out what comes next. It pretty much just comes down to if I'm contributing to giving her a mouthpiece or supporting her financially, which I hope I am not doing :V


I hope that you still keep your passion for doing art, even if it's for SSSS after it's become totally different from what you first saw.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: JoB on December 11, 2021, 04:45:26 AM
I've also noticed this! Minna and the artist for YIH for one. I think the author might've been inspired by Minna, considering the publishing date and, as I've heard but not seen, the appearance of Reynir?
I cannot offhand find a better source than this (https://ssssforum.com/index.php?topic=278.msg130598#msg130598), but YiH officially is an SSSS-inspired work.

Spoiler: personal thoughts on the topic • show

A handful of people have probably spent a load of money on SSSS books, and I know that's given a few of my friends a lot of conflicting emotions recently. But also how could they have known? [...] It pretty much just comes down to if I'm contributing to giving her a mouthpiece or supporting her financially, which I hope I am not doing :V

Spoiler: show

Honestly though, I'm not sure whether "LP pays way more bills than still-running SSSS does, why would I ever go back to that?" is a message that we want received, either.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on December 11, 2021, 09:07:55 AM
I think I’ll come back to some of this later, but just a comment on YIH. Jaakko is not Reynir, although the resemblance is striking. He’s a crossover character from Tistow, another fantasy webcomic by Finnish artist Elli Puukangas. MiikkaH (YIH artist) amd Elli have done also also collaborations. Tistow has unfortunately been removed, restarted fom beginning and gone on hiatus in 2020. Anyways Miikka makes it clear somewhere thst they did a character swap so Jahko is in YIH and someone (I think Veeti but not sure) in Tistow, except that the restarted version isn’t there yet.

As mentioned, the resemblance is striking, but then again they all are a bit ”stereotypical red-haired Viking” so it’s no wonder. Jaakko has pointy ears, which apparently has some signifigance that will come to light later. Jaakko is more assertive and decisive than Reynir, and well established in his environment, and also he’s a smith and not a magic-user, so as a character he’s not that similar.

I read somewhere on the Forum, possibly the LP thread, that the relationship between SSSS and YIH has been complicated. Some unfortunate segment of readers had found YIH via SSSS. I don’t know more about this, but I am very sorry to say that Nordic paganism is of interest also to groups who have a very different approach than we do here on the Forum. Luckily we have only very rarely seen attempts to bring that sort of discussion here! This is of course thanks to the long term decisive efforts of the admin team.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Kevin_Redcrow on December 11, 2021, 06:02:47 PM
I've also noticed this! Minna and the artist for YIH for one. I think the author might've been inspired by Minna, considering the publishing date and, as I've heard but not seen, the appearance of Reynir? Also, a lot of popular Finnish artists seem to know a great deal about painting nature, but I think that might veer a little too close to speculation. But nature's a pretty big deal in Finland :P

I get that. In the comic panels which have large rocks and boulders they have these large spots which puzzled me to no end. Then when I saw the music video of Jean Sibelius' Finlandia I went, "oooohhhhh! The spots are lichen!" Ms. Sundberg's rending of that was very, very good. I simply did not know what I was looking at.


Side note, Minna's made it pretty clear that she doesn't intend for other people to complete things she started. I'm fine with that, honestly. But hypothetically, YIH does look visually close


Yeah, it would be too much to hope for.

Eeeeeee... Minna's actions kind of used up any remaining goodwill I had. But she has her boundaries and even if that bunny comic personally insulted someone, she probably wasn't willing to have a debate about it anyway. It's more just energy better spent elsewhere.

"eeeeeee"  --I'm really going to miss "hearing" Tuuri say that!  What I meant by goodwill is how nicely people in the commentariate and forum behave.  I have a sense that Ms. Sundberg and I share the Spikiness Trait. I have to monitor what comes out of my mouth lest I  say something cluelessly offensive.

When the controversy over Emil's racist word in the original dialog was going on, I thought it was simply a portrayal of Emil's cultural ignorance by uttering such a gaffe. At the time I attributed this gaffe to his personality. I recalled how insulting Emil was when he demonstrated how Danish-speakers sounded to him. But I wasn't reading the Forum or the comments at the time.and didn't have the full picture.

The image of the glowering Danes in the background and Emil's guilty expression still makes me smile. In my version, the least that would have happened is Emil would then be running away like hell, with Mikkel intervening and calming people down.

You are correct. She probably would not wanted to waste the time. In my opinion, debating belief systems ranks below, far below; such foolish pastimes as producing and playing video games in terms spending one's time.  ;) 

After a brief period of being a born-again christian in my teens, I read up on Eastern religions and philosophy. I would leap into a debate with people "witnessing" at the drop of a hat. My intention was, if they are gonna try to convert me, I was gonna try to deprogram them. As I grew older this desire fell away, and I virtually never have anybody try to engage me with the intent of witnessing. For one thing, I can smell a cue-up to witnessing session a mile away.

[/quote]
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on December 15, 2021, 02:51:20 PM
Yeah, well, here we are, back to civilization. I do NOT believe this was not cut short.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on December 15, 2021, 05:16:52 PM
Yeah, she's probably just trying to get out of this.

Let's get out of it with all the remaining team still alive, shall we? -- I hope!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on December 15, 2021, 06:16:24 PM
I’m curious to see whether any one of them is carrying a kade fragment.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on December 16, 2021, 03:30:45 PM
Notice how we’ve gone from “Oh no, it can’t be ending yet!” to “Oh no hope it ends soon, before something gets ruined!”

I’m not seriously worried she would spring a totally horrible ending, but some pretty dim alternatives have been floated on Disqus.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on December 16, 2021, 05:36:54 PM
Notice how we’ve gone from “Oh no, it can’t be ending yet!” to “Oh no hope it ends soon, before something gets ruined!”

-- you know, you're right. I'm not sure when I made that shift; but I've definitely made it.

Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on December 16, 2021, 05:53:08 PM
I also noticed very recently, but then realized I have been thinking that for a while now.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Superdark33 on December 17, 2021, 09:20:44 AM
SSSS has been part of my life for a long time, and the community has been so dear to me that i have not left it despite being disgusted with the comic and its author for years.

Im not surprised that its about to end with a whimper and no closure, Minna never truly was able to deliver on anything other than art.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Straffe Recensent on December 19, 2021, 01:46:59 PM
SSSS has been part of my life for a long time, and the community has been so dear to me that i have not left it despite being disgusted with the comic and its author for years.

Im not surprised that its about to end with a whimper and no closure, Minna never truly was able to deliver on anything other than art.
I'm a bit out of the loop, what specifically are you referring to? I've only ever read the comic ...
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on December 19, 2021, 04:36:27 PM
Minna never truly was able to deliver on anything other than art.

I'm now imagining what might have happened if she'd been working, as an artist, with someone else who was doing much of the writing.

Most works that update anywhere near as frequently as SSSS (and some that don't) are the work of more than one person. And someone to work back and forth with as to what makes sense and works out well in the overall story and what doesn't, and to explain likely perceptions of others about such things as the Bad Joke Emil incident (and I'd hope to have prevented that in the first place), as well as to take some of the load and therefore reduce exhaustion -- that might have made a huge amount of difference.

Depending, of course, on who the other person was and what their attitudes were.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 06, 2022, 03:14:51 PM
Well then. Here we are. I’m sad, but less sad than I thought. I guess I’m also relieved to not have anything completely ruinous happen. Still…


(https://41.media.tumblr.com/c19a4d8427cb7adab9df7b09179f25f5/tumblr_inline_nodwi9LFZy1r2g2kx_540.png)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Vulpes on January 06, 2022, 08:26:02 PM
Well then. Here we are. I’m sad, but less sad than I thought.

I guess we've had a while to get used to the idea. I feel rather the same. At least she's fine with us applying our imaginations to her characters and settings.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Lueley on January 07, 2022, 07:55:15 AM
It's crazy to think after 7 years, I won't be starting my day by checking the new SSSS page anymore.

I'd struggle to do justice to how influential SSSS has been on my life. Minna's aesthetics and characterisation, and the incredibly talented authors on AO3, have both taught me a lot about writing and helped me to develop my own craft. When I started reading the comic, way back around the time that Emil encounters the dog-beast, I was only 14 years old- I'm 20 now. Finding this fan community: a community of likeminded artists, linguists, writers and folklore-lovers (no matter how infrequent I am with posting here or on AO3) helped me be confident in myself and embrace my interests. These days, I'm doing a linguistics and literature degree, fluent in languages I never thought I'd be able to learn, and following my passion for writing. I've got involved with the hiking and wild-camping community in my area, gone on the most amazing adventures, and made friends for life. I can safely say I might have never found this path for myself if it hadn't been for Minna, the community here, and the inspirational characters of SSSS.

So the end of comic is definitely a big moment for me- but I'm not sad about it. I've seen many webcomics drag on too long, have the artist lose passion, have the art and the storyline dry up in quality, and fizzle out. SSSS's endurance and Minna's tenacity have been frankly astounding compared to the norm for most online works like this. We all knew it would have to end at some point, however, and I think it's reached a natural stopping point. Is it sad it's ending? Perhaps. But it's been a fantastic journey, and I wouldn't want to see it spoiled by an author who can't commit to it anymore.
We've all noticed the plot, and the art style, losing their oomph as time goes on. It wouldn't make sense for the comic to continue now that Minna is not able to put the same love and pride into the comic, and I hope she finds a new project that she can put as much dedication and talent into as she did in earlier days with SSSS. Even if I'm not likely to follow her career on after this, I know I'll still keep loving and rereading SSSS, particularly Adventure 1 (I'm less fussed about Adventure 2 haha) and of course I'll still be writing my fanfiction for it. God knows I'm in the middle of writing an epic fic and I'm not giving up just because the comic is ending.

I hope the comic ends well, in a nice cozy way. Also, even if Emil and Lalli won't become canon official, my headcanon will still live strong.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: wavewright62 on January 08, 2022, 02:36:09 AM
I admit that I actually kinda like the bear shuffling around. 
(https://36.media.tumblr.com/a4099ecc88446f5237236a3f288555cf/tumblr_inline_np25eidGTw1r2g2kx_540.png)
Hear me out!  Juxtaposed with the kallohonka, it feels to me like a cycle of regeneration (although obviously *that* bear is not a direct rebirth of our poor maligned beasts), and I can imagine Mielikki and Tapio are doing their best.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 08, 2022, 06:36:24 AM
Lueley, I’m certain that Emilalli will not be established in canon. I don’t think it ever was going to be, but especially now. Her church doesn’t approve. But as already mentioned, I don’t think it, or any romantic relationships, was ever intended to be openly written in. The Sig/Mik thing is surprisingly clear lately.

On the other hand I don’t see how it could be canonically mad impossible short of killing one of them, which I sincerely hope is not in the cards at least anymore.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: tehta on January 08, 2022, 08:18:33 AM
I mean, there  are quite a few pages of plotless updates left, plenty of time for Lalli to meet a nice Finnish girl while hanging out on that balcony all winter.

(If we're not getting any more plot or hints of future adventure, I would almost prefer for the comic to end now. Not just because of potential emilalli jossing: because I worry that theological themes will seep in somehow, and I don't think I would enjoy that at all.)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on January 08, 2022, 10:16:13 AM
Even if Lalli does meet a nice Finnish girl: the romantic relationships that people start off with are very often not the ones they wind up with. So even if Minna puts such a thing in the epilogue, I don't see why people can't fanfic away.

(I suppose she could show them all happily married in year 110 with six kids each. But open marriages exist . . . and look at what Bujold did in-canon with one of her solidest Vorkosigan-saga marriages!)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 08, 2022, 11:11:55 AM
My point exactly, even if one of them (or both) married, it would not have to mean they wouldn’t get together at a later date, or now for that matter.

For example I assume having children is something that would be strongly expected from both of them, being immune and Lalli a noita related to other powerful noita. They could well marry women and have children, and the whole thing could be based on all parties knowing and agreeing the marriage is to produce children and their real partnership is with each other.

Or, they are perhaps not very skilled with emotions, so one or both could easily be seen as “floating” into a heterosexual marriage because that’s how it tends to go, and then realize later that you are not supposed to feel like your marriage is nothing but a chore.

Even saying out loud “I’m not gay” could well be denial, or missing understanding of oneself, or just confusion of a youngster.

We don’t really know anything about relationships and family forming customs in the Known World, so we can come up with anything :)

Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: moredhel on January 08, 2022, 12:27:19 PM
Even saying out loud “I’m not gay” could well be denial, or missing understanding of oneself, or just confusion of a youngster.
Absolutely seconding this. There is a lot of confusion going on in the wide land of queerness.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: tehta on January 08, 2022, 12:37:57 PM
Sure, we can write our way around anything: marriages, loss of competence, religious conversions. Or death. (If I ever write some post-canon adventures for the crew, I would very much like to resurrect Tuuri.) But if the next few pages contradict my headcanons for the characters directly, I'll feel sad.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 08, 2022, 12:43:25 PM
Agreed, I hope it doesn't come to that!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on January 08, 2022, 03:32:03 PM
My point exactly, even if one of them (or both) married, it would not have to mean they wouldn’t get together at a later date, or now for that matter.

For example I assume having children is something that would be strongly expected from both of them, being immune and Lalli a noita related to other powerful noita. They could well marry women and have children, and the whole thing could be based on all parties knowing and agreeing the marriage is to produce children and their real partnership is with each other.

Or, they are perhaps not very skilled with emotions, so one or both could easily be seen as “floating” into a heterosexual marriage because that’s how it tends to go, and then realize later that you are not supposed to feel like your marriage is nothing but a chore.

Even saying out loud “I’m not gay” could well be denial, or missing understanding of oneself, or just confusion of a youngster.

We don’t really know anything about relationships and family forming customs in the Known World, so we can come up with anything :)

Or they could be bi; and the Known World could have either formal or informal setups to acknowledge multiple relationships.

Or, for that matter, the Known World could have either formally or informally acknowledged processes for same-sex couples to produce, and to have the option to raise, children. -- don't we have at least one example of that in fanfic already?
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on January 08, 2022, 04:47:49 PM
Or we could have the situation often seen in the Nordic sagas and the Celtic hero-tales, where the bond between the heroes, the saga-friendship or soul-mate thing, transcends ordinary relationships and remains through marriage or the changes of politics. One of the things I do in the world is tell traditional stories, so that those old tales are not lost, and one such tale that has deep resonances with those who have known such friendships is ‘The Fight at the Ford’ from the Irish epic of the Tain. The two heroes wind up on opposite sides in a war, through obligations that they cannot avoid, one of them kills the other, and the resulting story is one of great beauty and power.

There are many such old tales in which the heroes may share families, or form a clan-like structure with several partners. Many ways their story might go.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: catbirds on January 08, 2022, 08:43:43 PM
Lueley, I’m certain that Emilalli will not be established in canon. I don’t think it ever was going to be, but especially now. Her church doesn’t approve. But as already mentioned, I don’t think it, or any romantic relationships, was ever intended to be openly written in. The Sig/Mik thing is surprisingly clear lately.

Outside of the realm of what this would mean for the comic, what exactly are the beliefs of "reformed baptist" christians in Finland? Especially in regards to homosexuality, gender, immigration (from places outside of western europe or from western europe), women, and wealth? I can find things related to "reformed" christians and "baptists" in general, but not for her specific sect and not for finnish or european christians of that sect.

Either way, given that she chose it herself and likes it, as opposed to, say, someone really young who grew up in it and just stays in it because they have no clue what else they'd do (does it even work that way?), I think it's safe to say she agrees with whatever the church believes on such matters.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: tehta on January 08, 2022, 09:08:50 PM
Minna has named her favourite theologians: John Piper and RC Sproul
Their views are easy to discover, but ooof. Personally, I wish I had not read the stuff on gender roles.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on January 08, 2022, 11:36:41 PM
Seems to me somewhat narrow and inhumane. People are as they are, and in my experience trying to impose a One True Way on everyone just doesn’t work. Ever. Respecting one another is so important.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: JoB on January 09, 2022, 01:49:23 AM
what exactly are the beliefs of "reformed baptist" christians in Finland? Especially in regards to homosexuality, gender, immigration (from places outside of western europe or from western europe), women, and wealth?
Hm. Wikipedia has a page on "Reformed Baptists (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reformed_Baptists)", and when I open the infobox's "Doctrine" section, "Separation of Church and State" and "Freedom of Religion" jump out to me ...

(Also, "sola scriptura", which I'd guess mostly nails down their views on gender roles. No idea so far about the rest of your keywords ...)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 09, 2022, 06:27:49 AM
I don’t know much about them, Baptism is tiny here in Finland with about 2000 members. I’m looking up some things, but I’lll have to write on the other computer later. Their stance towards homosexuality I checked before I wrote the above. They don’t approve gay marriage, it’s actually written in their rules that marriage is between man and woman. There are not many such questions in their rules, which mostly cover the organization of the parishes and the church. Equal marriage has been an issue for a few years now, and our main church (Evangelical Lutheran) is struggling with it. Civil marriage is equal in Finland since a few years.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: catbirds on January 09, 2022, 11:58:14 AM
Man, I still want to see SSSS through to the end, since we were So close anyway… but the facts are gradually getting harder to swallow and easier to see.

Hm. Wikipedia has a page on "Reformed Baptists (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Reformed_Baptists)", and when I open the infobox's "Doctrine" section, "Separation of Church and State" and "Freedom of Religion" jump out to me ...

(Also, "sola scriptura", which I'd guess mostly nails down their views on gender roles. No idea so far about the rest of your keywords ...)

A lot of theological debates go on about the soul, the scripture, etc but end up applying it to reality in incredibly variable ways, so I wouldn't care much about what they say they believe in theory. And a lot of sects who have "freedom of religion," whatever that means, still have islamophobia, antisemitism, or idk maybe just disapproving of other religions anyway?? I think in history class we learned that the original meaning was just freedom to practise religion, with naught to do with actually changing your beliefs. I have no idea what this means or how it applies to reality… meh.

Anyway, the keywords are mostly just to gauge just how… bad? The sect is? I mean, disapproving of homophobia or immigration or whatever is bad enough on its own, but it would help people figure out what's going on in LP and future works (Also if you tick off enough boxes it's basically a hate group… um)

Minna has named her favourite theologians: John Piper and RC Sproul
Their views are easy to discover, but ooof. Personally, I wish I had not read the stuff on gender roles.

Could only find a wiki article of one of their beliefs, and a long, long reading list of every other one. I am afraid to find out what they're about…

I don’t know much about them, Baptism is tiny here in Finland with about 2000 members. I’m looking up some things, but I’lll have to write on the other computer later. Their stance towards homosexuality I checked before I wrote the above. They don’t approve gay marriage, it’s actually written in their rules that marriage is between man and woman. There are not many such questions in their rules, which mostly cover the organization of the parishes and the church. Equal marriage has been an issue for a few years now, and our main church (Evangelical Lutheran) is struggling with it. Civil marriage is equal in Finland since a few years.

EEeeeee… yikes! Well. It's nice to get confirmation after the mess of LP that was "social justice is going to destroy our society" … well, it's bad news, actually.

The whole "rigid gender roles only" thing does go hand-in-hand with homophobia.

Uhffff… dare I ask… about their stance on vaccines? (considering all the grumbling at the end of LP…)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on January 09, 2022, 06:36:40 PM
I can’t really find anything about their stance towards vaccination. Like I said, they are tiny, so I assume many issues they simply talk about when meeting. The Pentecostals and Free Church, which are very close with baptists and very much bigger, are both urging their members to get vaccinated. Some people are speaking against vaccines on religious grounds, but it seems that the organizations themselves are trying to stop such foolishness. Several Christian media have published articles warning against false accusations against vaccines. All in all anti-vaxxers aren’t as commonly religious as in many other countries.

I have read a lot more about baptism in Finland than I really wanted to know :) I’ve also been surprised that these churches are so tiny (in Finland), yet we learned about all of them in school, in religious studies (which we unfortunately have). About 2000 baptists and even fewer methodists and adventists. Pentecostals are the largest of these, which are called Free Christians or something like that here, there are over 40 000 Pentecostals. Many baptist and pentecostal congregations and other organizations are close and cooperate a lot.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: mirrorsmirror on January 16, 2022, 10:04:59 PM
Honestly, I wonder what her tradwife blog is. Because the fact that she likes some popular american theologians instead of looking into ones from her own country makes me think she has fallen into some reactionary online trad/conservative rabbit hole during the pandemic, maybe through her interest in nordic pagan stuff because those spaces are infested with these young new born christians reactionaries types and that's how were here. I don't want to disrespect anyone's religion but that's honestly what this all seems like, since this happened now when this kind of thing has become it's own movement and subculture on the internet. She apparently is the kind of person who spends a lot of time on the computer, it would make sense after the different kind of dramas that happened with racism and such, like that made her angry and then she has found some trad anti-woke people from the internet and got sucked into that kind of thing.

edit: Also, her weird "cities make people sick" is the exact kind of dicourse in those kind of spaces
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Lenny on January 17, 2022, 04:57:00 AM
Honestly, I wonder what her tradwife blog is. Because the fact that she likes some popular american theologians instead of looking into ones from her own country makes me think she has fallen into some reactionary online trad/conservative rabbit hole during the pandemic, maybe through her interest in nordic pagan stuff because those spaces are infested with these young new born christians reactionaries types and that's how were here.

This is actually exactly what I've been thinking since the whole LP thing, and the name-dropping of those theologians has, at least in my mind, confirmed it. I think order of operations was get into an online community, and then find a local community that matches up with it. I think that trying to figure out her views from the small Baptist community she's joined, or analysing any of the more popular Finnish denominations, would be less productive than going after the theologians she's mentioned and seeing in what online communities they're popular, or what kind of influencers are pushing them. Looking at Lutheranism would only be useful to see what she grew up in and how that shaped her current views, but not her current views.

I'm not actually going to do any of that, and I don't really recommend that anyone else does either, it's not worth the effort. Her first new comic should have more than enough information about it, with less guesswork and analysing a stranger, and less chance of coming across some communities that you would rather not be part of.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Lenny on January 17, 2022, 05:16:36 AM
SSSS has been part of my life for a long time, and the community has been so dear to me that i have not left it despite being disgusted with the comic and its author for years.

Im not surprised that its about to end with a whimper and no closure, Minna never truly was able to deliver on anything other than art.
As for my thoughts on the end of the comic, very similar to Super.


I've been reading SSSS since a few months before the forum was created. Minna initially inspired me quite a bit, showing me that oh, it is possible to do comics as an individual, which led to my own webtoon being made (and then abandoned as life got way, way too much). The community has been and hopefully will continue to be one of the best I've ever been in. I've made some incredible friends here, and even found my spouse via the fandom.

But I stopped reading SSSS a long while ago, at Tuuri's death. At that point I was really just reading out of habit, the story had dipped for a while and Tuuri was a highlight. It might read better paced now that Adventure 1 is complete and able to be read in one go, but at the time it was difficult. It was also soured by some of Minna's actions back then. I was hoping that I'd be able to go back and see the author improve, but for me, the opposite has happened. And now that she's irreversibly intertwined with one of my most complicated traumas I doubt I'll be able to go back and read again for a long while.

It feels a bit sad seeing it end like this. But I think for me it's mostly sadness for what could have been. I still plan on being around here and the other communities made, being part of a community for 8 years doesn't end just because the thing it was based around ended. I like the people here, and I don't want that to not be part of my life any more :>
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on January 17, 2022, 07:43:47 PM
Agreed, Lenny. This community is a joy, I have certainly made some good friends through it. Who knows, I might even get to meet you in person? Both of us have kin in Tasmania, I think?
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Lenny on January 19, 2022, 04:57:48 AM
Agreed, Lenny. This community is a joy, I have certainly made some good friends through it. Who knows, I might even get to meet you in person? Both of us have kin in Tasmania, I think?

I hope so, I would love that! I love your stories, and I'd love to meet you in person, you seem like someone I'd respect and like a whole lot. I still have one sibling in Tasmania, and a whole lot of friends. I've got another good friend I made via the SSSS irc chat in Adelaide, too, and another old friend in Queensland, so I've got good reason to pop back and do a trip around the country!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on January 19, 2022, 09:01:26 AM
I am at the edge of Mount Pleasant, a small bush town in that area where the Murraylands, the Barossa and the Adelaide Hills meet. Accomodation at my place is usually a swag by the fire, but if you need something fancier there is a decent motel and several nice B&Bs, at least one of them being walking distance from my place. We must have a meetup with some of the other locals if you visit; maybe we could invite Dai?
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: John Candlebury on February 02, 2022, 11:05:15 AM
Must say that even though Im sad the comics ended, at least im glad they did so with a nice conclusion story wise.
It was a really nice to be able to track the updates for almost a decade, and see the story actually end.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on February 02, 2022, 12:48:11 PM
Hello Citizen! We are glad to have you back! As you may have noticed already, we intend to keep going, and YOU are invited!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: White_Tiger on March 16, 2022, 08:31:39 AM
Must say that even though Im sad the comics ended, at least im glad they did so with a nice conclusion story wise.
It was a really nice to be able to track the updates for almost a decade, and see the story actually end.

Absolutely, the fact that we got to enjoy a story with such high output (I did and still do think that four pages a week, with the art being as high quality as it is, is crazy - it was honestly inspiring and got me to start drawing again) for almost eight and a half years with pretty much no interruption is incredible, not to mention an exceedingly rare find. I'm super bummed it's ending now, especially considering the circumstances, but at the very least we got a tidy end. I'd have been crushed if it got abandoned halfway through a storyline with no explanation (though it may have been preferrable, considering the whole Minna-joining-a-cult thing, hope she does alright. Reading LP's unedited afterword for the first time with no warning was a bit of a smack in the face but i digress). But the spirit of SSSS shall live on in the fandom. Butter good!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on March 16, 2022, 12:27:42 PM
I do wonder whether that frequent update schedule contributed to the ending, however. While people do have drastically different energy levels, I wonder whether Minna hadn't spent most of those eight and a half years in a state of chronic exhaustion; which can definitely affect somebody's thinking processes and decision making.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: lwise on March 16, 2022, 01:32:08 PM
Initially she did five pages a week, which is even more incredible.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: White_Tiger on March 16, 2022, 02:42:46 PM
Five?! That's . . . impressive and a little concerning. I think it's quite possible it contributed. I don't know her, and I never will, but
I'd be hard pressed to believe it didn't contribute to the ending to some extent.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on March 27, 2022, 05:15:10 PM
So. Here we are. I’m somewhat out of Feels right now. I guess I have mourned enough already?

But not all is lost! Here’s a little note I wrote last October for the YoinkTober event on the prompt Community.

Community

Dust. Dust gets everywhere. Dust builds up in the empty hallways and hangs in the air of venues no longer used. We have sealed off several wings of empty space. We don’t have the resources to man it all. It's down to the force fields now, they are all that's keeping us safe. The Tesla coil lies in disrepair (we assume - no one dares touch it). The brewery equipment has lost its sheen.

Yet not all is lost. The Bakery is still in production. The Moose still comes every now and then. Promotion Celebrations still take place on the Main Square, and every now and then the Inner Door opens, and we welcome another one. We have lost many, but we have gained many. And we still do.

New shops are opening on the World and Stories Alley. Some of them are already fairly popular, and we hope to see more. The Creative Corner remains lively, with Haikus traded back and forth and art still gathering crowds. Events Street is currently brightly lit with YoinkTober lanterns, and hopefully it will soon see yet another Yuletide.

We have lost much, but we have gained much. Where there is life, there is hope. The Blanket Fort is the symbol of our hope and our community. Today, again, we dust the used areas, let in the fresh air, and turn on the lights. All are welcome! We have cookies! And cake! And confetti! Not to forget hope.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on March 27, 2022, 09:15:29 PM
I had missed that piece, or don’t remember it anymore. I love it. The Community goes on.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on March 27, 2022, 11:07:00 PM
Yup. It's happened. We're out on our own.

Out on our own may turn out to be quite an interesting place, though --
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: philman on March 28, 2022, 02:20:22 AM
I have to admit, despite it being over, and the circumstances behind that, I actually quite like the ending comic wise. We got some nice little moments with all the characters, got to say goodbye to most of them, they're generally happy and safe, it was an actual ending and not completely abrupt like some webcomics, while plenty of scope for picking it up again in the future, either for Minna or fanfic writers.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Keep Looking on March 28, 2022, 05:48:49 AM
Jitter, thank you for re-posting a very fitting farewell to the comic.

Personally, I'm surprised at the lack of intensity of my feelings about the ending. I think this is possibly because my investment for SSSS as the actual comic has waned quite a lot over the past year and a half. Right now, the significance that SSSS holds to me is contained within the communities it has created - all the people I've met and all the wonderful things everybody's made and said and done. Still, it's an odd feeling to know that there won't be any more discussion or speculation about the updates, regardless of its level of excitement or cynicism. I'm glad that SSSS got an ending, even if it was rather lacklustre, and didn't just cut off abruptly. I suppose I appreciate a sense of closure.

I hope this community won't be going away anytime soon! The SSSS fandom - in the comments, on the forum and on the discord (which you can join here (https://discord.com/invite/0zhJ8tFPMIqiPf1N), if anyone's interested) - has been a massive part of my life these past three years: getting me back into poetry, allowing me to meet so many wonderful people from all over the world, and also teaching me a surprisingly large amount of new skills - from organising events to learning how websites work behind the scenes as I've become an admin. Us admins and mods will do our best to keep this site running as long as there's people who want to come here.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: dmeck7755 on March 28, 2022, 08:02:32 AM
now it is up to us to keep the dust and cobwebs away.  And maybe hunt a few trolls
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: midwestmutt on March 28, 2022, 11:24:39 AM
This is not the end, just a new phase. As for myself I will continue checking the forum daily as part of my morning routine. I look for new art and photos of the routes our heroes took as well as vacation posts from members as they travel. I contribute to photos myself, in particular with snaps of the reenactor timeline events I attend. I recently opened a YouTube site so I could post videos of me playing music which I will continue as I learn how to improve the quality of my vids made on my smartphone. I just bought a microphone which plugs into my phone and installed a camera app to improve audio and am pleased with the results. There are several excellent fanfics on sites like Archive of our Own which you can follow, some that are entirely new stories and others that provide interesting background to the canon timeline. In this way the community and the story can continue.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on March 28, 2022, 02:17:59 PM
Hear hear, midwestmutt!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Linebyline on March 31, 2022, 09:28:53 AM
I share people's feelings about parts of the ending feeling perfunctory or anticlimactic, and some loose threads being abandoned. The epilogue was lovely, though. My main beef is that we didn't get much of a goodbye for Tuuri. I don't know, maybe I just missed it? Maybe I skipped a page? But it feels like she was there and then she was gone.

On that note, I feel like Adventure 2 was a good place to end things. I love the idea that the surviving crew can always go on having adventures--that's one of my favorite kinds of endings--but it just isn't SSSS without Tuuri and it would really start to get unbelievable to have her keep coming back from the dead every time the rest want to go on an adventure.

Overall, while some things could have been handled better, I'm happy enough with what we got. I'm sad to see it end, but it's a happy kind of sad, if that makes sense.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on April 04, 2022, 02:13:25 PM
Hee! We may be weird but we are not alone!

Here’s an article citing actual psychologist about Post-Series Depression and how to deal with it! It’s a Thing! We have a Thing!

https://melmagazine.com/en-us/story/psychologists-on-how-to-fill-the-emptiness-you-feel-after-binging-a-great-show
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: lwise on April 04, 2022, 02:32:33 PM
Apropos of nothing, I'm reading a book called "The Great Quake: How the Biggest Earthquake in North America Changed Our Understanding of the Planet."  I've just been introduced to Kris Madsen: "A tall, skinny girl with blue eyes and unbelievably red hair, she developed an independent streak from an early age."

She appears to be the temporally misplaced daughter of Mikkel Madsen and Sigrun Eide!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: NightMareMage on April 07, 2022, 05:25:25 PM
This is kinda late but whatever.

Most of my feelings on it's ending went before the epilogue. I was frustrated with the lack of closure with the defeat of the kade, the freeing of Ensi and with Tuuri's farewell (mostly that last one). I don't really hate the bears but I never felt much for them either and they had a better resolution with did not help my frustration.

The epilogue was cute though.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: midwestmutt on April 09, 2022, 09:46:23 AM
I deleted SSSS from my bookmarks. End of an era.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on April 10, 2022, 05:37:28 AM
Jitter, that was a fascinating article! SSSS being my first web community, though I am involved in a number of real world communities, it was a whole new experience for me. And I hope to maintain through the ongoing Forum the connections I have made here, some of which have spilled over into the real world and are likely to continue there. There are many folk I have met through the Forum and the comic whom I would hope to know better. And I have learned so much!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: dreki on October 01, 2022, 02:27:49 AM
This is kinda late but whatever.

Most of my feelings on it's ending went before the epilogue. I was frustrated with the lack of closure with the defeat of the kade, the freeing of Ensi and with Tuuri's farewell (mostly that last one). I don't really hate the bears but I never felt much for them either and they had a better resolution with did not help my frustration.

The epilogue was cute though.

I just finished rereading and ... Yeah.

I'm glad she finished it. But you can tell she fell out of love and wanted it done.

I do think it's a good place to end. In part because it feels quite possible that the crew will naturally part ways once the travel opens back up.

Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: dinoonthenet on November 29, 2022, 09:56:11 PM
i found ssss during the end of adventure II (from an advertisement on flight rising, of all places), so i never got a chance to participate in the fandom in its peak. even so, i have a lot of thoughts and feelings about the comic that have been stewing in my head. it feels right to set them free here.

i could tell at first glance the story was very much to my tastes - the post-apocalyptic winter setting, the unique artstyle, the focus on language, and so much more, it was unlike anything i'd ever seen before, and very much like something i'd been wanting to see and lacking in other works. and so i decided to save it for later, for when i feel ready to delve into something new to be passionate about. this "later" turned out to be when i was going through some dark times in my personal life, and i stayed up several nights binging the entire comic from start to most recent page (it was around the final confrontation with the kade, i think).

i was hooked. it was everything i hoped it would be and more. i loved the art, i loved the atmosphere, and i especially loved the characters and their interactions. Lalli, particularly, is very dear to me. i myself am autistic, and i'd never seen a character so openly display such familiar mannerisms without being judged or "fixed" by the narrative or other characters. it felt like a breath of fresh air when i hadn't realized i'd been holding it. seeing the team bond and face the horrors of the silent world together did wonders to lift my spirits when i was feeling so low. i had a couple issues with the story - mostly the worldbuilding and how eager to forget itself the world seemed (i mean, 90 years? that's nothing in the face of history) - but i didn't care, because what i loved about it was just so much stronger and brighter.

then i got to adventure II and it started falling apart a more and more. like many others, i noticed the comic lose steam. i didn't much blame the author for any art changes (making comics is exhausting!!), but the story started to feel... hollow. empty. uninterested in itself. i know now, but at the time i didn't understand why so many cool concepts and plot threads that had been set up were quietly dropped, why the characters didn't seem to even interact anymore, why the death of one of them seemed to not affect anyone, why the creeping, ever present horror of the silent world was replaced by... three bears. i was a bit in denial. i wanted to love adventure II like i loved adventure I, still feeling the buzz of excitement from binging it in just a few days, but that feeling was quickly crushed when i learned about the author's newest work and the motivation behind it. it made everything click into place, and one morbid curiosity induced cartoon animal comic read later, i was back in that dark pit that ssss originally pulled me out of. i'm not sure it makes sense for me to be affected so deeply, when my experience with the comic was so short lived, but i suppose i can't tell the heart how strongly to feel about something.

since then i've gone back to revisit the story, read it again with a clearer mind and knowledge of where it was going. i looked at it with an analytical lens, picked apart its themes and details in my head. it could easily be considered a hyperfixation, i think. i mulled over the story and all the potential for where it and any derivative works could have gone, like nervously turning over a smooth pebble in your pocket to calm your nerves, over and over. i read through the (very impressive) library of fanworks, and of course, this forum. it took a whole lot of anxious second-guessing, but i finally made the decision to join, to not keep all of that (and wow, this is much more than i even realized i could write, i hope it isn't too much) inside my head.

i'm here now. i don't know how much i have to contribute, if anything, but i want to try. because ssss and all that it's inspired deserve better than to be forgotten.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on November 30, 2022, 12:33:49 PM
Dinoonthenet, thank you for posting this! And thank you for joining us. I think most of us still sticking to the Forum feel the same, although friendships and community also plays a part in why we are not planning to give up the Forum or the Known World.

I’ve bn around longer than you, since early Adv II but still not in the heyday. And I shared your feelings about “is it ok for me to be this upset”, but I’ve gotten over it since. I love you Forumites, and I love the team ad the world, despite the shortcomings* that are sometimes so glaringly obvious that I have to wonder how I disregarded them earlier, but I’m very happy that I did or otherwise I wouldn’t be here :)

If you’ve read through the Forum (surely not ALL of it? I know I haven’t and I’m pretty manic about it) you know how shattered we were and how close we came to actually closing shop. I’m very glad we didn’t. And extremely glad that we still get new people! Participate in the discussions as much or a little as you like (although I personally prefer much), everything counts!

* shortcomings in the worldbuilding and later perhaps with development or lack of it of the team. The Forumites of course have no shortcomings!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on November 30, 2022, 06:10:28 PM
ssss and all that it's inspired deserve better than to be forgotten.

Indeed. Including by its author; who very unfortunately (IMO) appears to want to do so.

Welcome very much here. This community seemed to me, and clearly to a number of its other members, to be something worth saving on its own; and, although we couldn't save SSSS, we can save this forum. And one of the reasons to save it is to provide a place for those who loved Adventure I and the first portions of Adventure II, and wish to keep a portion of themselves living in that world.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on March 28, 2023, 02:27:49 PM
Today, March 28th 2023 is the first anniversary post-comic. It’s been a difficult year, for the world and for the fandom. But still, in the undying (pun shamelessly intended) words of Granny Weatherwax of Discworld fame, WE ATEN’T DEAD! It’s something, don’t you think?
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: dmeck7755 on March 28, 2023, 05:08:17 PM
Today, March 28th 2023 is the first anniversary post-comic. It’s been a difficult year, for the world and for the fandom. But still, in the undying (pun shamelessly intended) words of Granny Weatherwax of Discworld fame, WE ATEN’T DEAD! It’s something, don’t you think?

/>
It has been great talking and meeting you all this past year. 
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: thorny on March 29, 2023, 12:07:49 AM
It is very definitely something, Jitter. And something good.

Happy Independence Anniversary to All!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on March 29, 2023, 12:40:41 AM
Seconding thorny on that! There is such a diverse group of fascinating people here that I hope to enjoy their company for a long time yet.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Buteo on March 29, 2023, 02:04:37 AM
Yes, Jitter, it is indeed something!

This forum is a treasure to me, even a lifeline!

May we all continue to enjoy this community for a long, long time!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Keep Looking on March 29, 2023, 02:05:00 AM
Yes, I'm glad we're still around! Although it feels weird to think that the comic has been finished for a year. Here's to another year forwards, though!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on March 29, 2023, 07:31:04 AM
Raises a glass to another year!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: NightMareMage on March 30, 2023, 01:30:00 AM
I think I found SSSS about a year and a half ago, and then I joined this forum while the epilogue was finishing. I just can't believe it's been a full year!

Happy day after the first anniversary of the post-comic!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 08, 2023, 05:06:50 PM
This is going to be a strange place to post this, but if I can see rightly some life still lives on in this forum and I have the strangest melancholy growing in my chest about it.

I remember reading SSSS back when I was younger - fifteen, I think, back when it all started. I kept up with it for a few years and then my life got busy and my brain decided to shift on to so many other things that all I really remembered was some beautiful art and some wonderful focus on languages. I never engaged with the fandom, or the community, and seeing what happened recently it's...very strange to feel sad about not doing that.

I decided to give the comic a reread just two days ago because I was talking about a setting of my own that I wrote back in the late 2010s as a place for a few friends to make up stories in and to roleplay around. Though it was inspired by dozens of other things there was Stand Still, Stay Silent in the DNA. Post-apocalypse, horror, and a desperate thirst for discovering what was lost and humanity clawing back after a lot of despair.

I decided, having started at page one (and going there from an ancient bookmark somewher near the end of Adventure I) to see how far I had to go, how much I could read before catching up again. Ten years worth of content, right? And now I have no idea if I even want to keep reading all the way to the end, even through stuff I've never seen before, because of the terrible weight of how the comic's ending came to be. I even read the author's statement about 'old works' and how she can't recommend them anymore and that makes me sad, deeply, as a writer myself. I couldn't imagine growing so distant from something I loved and poured my heart into.

This is just a very long way of saying - I can't imagine all the pain at the slow decline, I can feel a sharp disappointment now on my own - not that it ended, but around how -, and that it's heartening to see people brought together by a creative work still holding on to each other.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: wavewright62 on July 08, 2023, 08:51:55 PM
Hi and welcome, Glass. 
(https://imgur.com/9Qj0YZk.png)


I certainly feel that, even though I lived through it.  For awhile it felt like:
(https://36.media.tumblr.com/e44f0a939f849a134295a6c92ac3743c/tumblr_inline_nrfy66vEKy1r2g2kx_540.png)
Interestingly, I have seen signs that a portion of the fandom is beginning to reclaim some of the SSSS worldbuilidng through fanworks.  The Russian fanbase is particularly active, I'm told (haven't fed those works into a translator personally). 
Shades of Monty Python - we're not dead yet, we're getting better!  (Do we feel like dancing? hmmmm)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 09, 2023, 10:56:20 AM
Hi Wave, thank you for the welcome - I'm glad to at least find people still around to empathise with the frankly weirdly complex feelings about a comic that's lived in the back of my mind for years.

And, knowing it's still being clawed back and kept alive by people's passion is a salve all on its own. The fact that the world had a spot in my head for nearly ten years, paying absolutely no rent mind you, is still being built on and treasured helps. Here's to things continuing to get better.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Buteo on July 09, 2023, 12:13:49 PM
Hello, Glass, welcome to the forum.

What you say about your feelings for the way SSSS ended strikes so many chords. Minna's abandonment of her creation hurt me deeply.

The attachment of so many readers who remained connected to that story, and to each other, has been healing and encouraging to me. I have sadly little life beyond this corner of the internet world, and with this as my haven I have the courage to venture further.

Have you been to Archive Of Our Own, the site where fanfiction and art flourish? Stand Still Stay Silent has some amazingly good writers and artists posting there. (Some of my favourites are alternative endings for Adventure II, but there are many other seriously good works.)

We are a smaller group than we were back in the 'good old days', but we are determined to keep the best of what we had then - including the friends we have made here: knowledgeable, caring, sharing, and kind. These can be the 'good new days'.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 09, 2023, 03:47:04 PM
Buteo, hello! It's been quite a while since I joined a forum - it's very nice to be welcomed.

 I'm glad I was at least mildly intelligable in my feeling filled rambling; it was all quite a rush of emotion in the space of a few hours on a Saturday afternoon. 

I have in fact heard of AO3 and have, once upon a time, actually written there. Being reminded of that makes starting something SSSS related quite tempting, or at the very least hunting down some tales written by people who still hold the world dear. Especially to salvage some of the enthusiasm the setting really left awoke in me.

For everything that burns down I suppose there's new ashes for things to grow in - so, 'the good new days' sounds more than pleasant. Even if I am falling in through the door to have a look around while the shoots are a fair bit grown.





Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on July 09, 2023, 07:53:01 PM
The good new days sounds wonderful!

Thank you Glass for your beautiful words. Like Buteo says, we're fewer but we are still around! And of course welcome to the forum! We have some squirrel cookies around, the head cookie baker (Mirasol) just came by with a fresh batch. You are welcome to share!

I myself joined the fandom late, after the heyest heyday (early days of Adventure 2), but the world, the characters and the community have become more than important to me. Also like Buteo said, your feelings are very familiar. It was different for us, who hoed and feared for the story and the characters as and when what happened, happened, but weirdly complex feelings is a good description. As you will see, if you read the various threads about the aftermath of “Lovely people” and then during the winding down of Adventure 2, it was weirdly complex for many of us. It still is. But we are around, and intend to stay here!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 09, 2023, 08:28:02 PM
I could never say no to cookies Jitter, thank you. As for the words; they're one of the things I think I'm okay at, and I'm glad you could see beauty in them.

I've taken a look at a few threads (including this one) and the reaction to Lovely People is telling all on its own. I don't think I'll be reading it, my feelings about Minna's work have already been soured enough. Though admittedly the reactions and opinions on this very forum have helped a great deal to even out the shock I was feeling a day or two ago, and I may or may not have started putting down Silent World related words.<.<

The resilience of the community here is something to admire. I'm glad to, even for a few moments, be around it - not to say I don't intend to take a look around and see where I can throw some thoughts, or what kind of people I can meet.

It's nice looking at a forum textbox again, as weird as that is to say.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on July 09, 2023, 11:24:43 PM
Hi Glass! Must be a bit of a shock to see the changes. I’ve been here since quite early days, and find it sad to see a brilliant making discarded so carelessly.

Still, one of the things I do in the real world is storyteller, and something I have discovered in the course of a long and varied life is that a story is a story, no matter whether it is an ancient folktale or a modern webcomic, and each story is a fertile substrate from which other tales may grow. That is human imagination, the craft of making, and the folk process.

I recommend this community’s deep and amazing stash of fanart, fanfic and creative speculation and discussion. We try to maintain the spirit of the original work. Join us and have fun!
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on July 10, 2023, 01:08:52 PM
I strongly recommend staying off Lovely People. It, and particularly the author comments at the ens, was so bad I stopped making voting reminders* in the Disqus comments because there was a huge LP banner and I didn’t want to promote it in any way. This is remarkable because I loved the reminders, and I don’t think we knew at that time SSSS was ending.

Some insight to Minna’s process of thinking and of faith can be found in her personal testimony comic A Meandering Line. It’s still not recommended unless you want a great big portion of Christianity, but it’s about her and not about what everyone else should do / believe and therefore a lot more palatable to me at least.

We’d love to see you stick around! If you do write something, do post on the Writing board (you can poat a link to AO3 or other fanfiction site, or post the work directly here, or both, as long as it’s PG-13 / T rated. There’s a separate board for mature works). And we have the ongoing ”forum event” Prompt of the Week, which could well be a low threshold way to stretch the writing muscles as drafts are very welcome!

* we used to vote for SSSS on thr TopWebComics list every day to get more readers, and someone would put in a reminder to do so every day. Until LP dropped that is.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 10, 2023, 07:27:03 PM
Hi Róisín, lovely to meet you - and you're more than right on feeling shocked. It's the comic book equivalent of an icy plunge, hah.

I recommend this community’s deep and amazing stash of fanart, fanfic and creative speculation and discussion. We try to maintain the spirit of the original work. Join us and have fun!

Do you happen to have any fanfic or the like that you particularly enjoy or would recommend?

Some insight to Minna’s process of thinking and of faith can be found in her personal testimony comic A Meandering Line. It’s still not recommended unless you want a great big portion of Christianity, but it’s about her and not about what everyone else should do / believe and therefore a lot more palatable to me at least.

I grew up around a lot of Christian sectarian violence - and a lot of the same questions Minna mentions in that testimony comic which I...admit I couldn't actually get all the way through. It felt very twee with the bunnys as people again, though maybe I'm still getting over my SSSS bitterness. Having gone through the dark tunnel of 'oh god eternity is a thing and we're a drop of sand in its neverending beach' I came out the other end still pretty firmly agnostic - so empathy for the fear there, sure, but a healthy bit of scorn that I probably shouldn't hold on to too tightly. 

We’d love to see you stick around! If you do write something, do post on the Writing board (you can poat a link to AO3 or other fanfiction site, or post the work directly here, or both, as long as it’s PG-13 / T rated. There’s a separate board for mature works). And we have the ongoing ”forum event” Prompt of the Week, which could well be a low threshold way to stretch the writing muscles as drafts are very welcome!

I do trend towards writing horror, as horifically as it comes, (and the body horror element of the Silent World still strikes me today) so I'm sure if I decide to put anything together for people to read the AO3 link will need dropped in that more mature section. The prompts sound fun though, I'm always looking for more excuses to write.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Keep Looking on July 10, 2023, 08:00:57 PM
(Hello, welcome, and yes - many people here hold onto the same sentiments about Minna's new work as you do)

Unfortunately ao3 is down so I can't provide links but I know a fan-favourite fic series is 'Kasvatus', which essentially continues the story after adventure 1 in a different direction. Lots of worldbuilding, lots of Emil/Lalli pining then 'Emil/Lalli moderate relational hurdles' as well as interesting exploration of other character relations as well, lots of sheep, interesting OCs, and plotlines that will make you want to keep turning the pages. Metaphorically.

We've also got the SSSS Scriptorium board (https://ssssforum.com/index.php?topic=193.0) on this forum which has a whole treasure trove of fic (many of which can be accessed without ao3, which is an advantage at the present moment)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Glass on July 11, 2023, 10:41:05 AM
I know I'm bouncing between here and the intro thread now but I wanted to be polite - thank you for the welcome, Looking, and the recommendation. I'll check it out once A03 is properly functional again; it's been a while since I read fanfiction but I have a strangely revived interest.

In the meantime I'll glance at the Scriptorum, and hopefully find a spark that kindles some inspiration.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on July 11, 2023, 11:24:31 PM
Fan writers I would recommend at first thought are Onnenlintu, JStevens, Jiiri (who is the same person as our Jitter). There are others whose work is equally good, but whose precise tags I can’t remember, and at present Archive is down from some kind of hacking incident. Hope it comes back, I have some work there myself. I’m Tanist there.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Jitter on July 12, 2023, 04:38:10 PM
Oh thank you Róisín! I’m honored!

One of the consequences of What Happened was that I nearly stopped writing. I have taken it up again but my main storyline(s, I think they will merge at some point) is more or less in a hiatus. At least the short stories and silly bits are all here too :)
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: LooNEY_DAC on July 12, 2023, 05:45:52 PM
There are others whose work is equally good, but whose precise tags I can’t remember...
SectoBoss.
OwlsG0/AuntyAgonee and Lazy8 orphaned their works but left them up, and the Index links still work.
Title: Re: Thoughts on the End of SSSS
Post by: Róisín on July 12, 2023, 11:32:46 PM
Yeah, definitely SectoBoss!